TCGAI.PRO Matthew Schaefer 2025-26 · Allure · #AR-MS
9.0 Mint
Consider
Matthew Schaefer card, TCGAI Score 9.0

Certificate #4D5DFF37A06A · Hockey

Matthew Schaefer

Allure · #AR-MS · 2025-26

Mint Consider

Consider. Send it if a 9 is still worth more than the fee.

Estimate, not an official grade.

Share on X

Condition report

Each check is scored out of 10 on both sides. The lowest one caps the TCGAI Score.

Front No flaws
Back No flaws

Sub-grades are not available for this certificate.

What the AI found

Flaws visible at the photo's resolution. A grader under magnification may find more. Marks on the photos show the area named, not an exact spot.

No defects listed at this photo resolution.

What this card sells for

An estimate from recent listings, not an appraisal. Prices in USD.

Graded 9

$350

$340 – $360 · 2 sales

Raw, ungraded

$33.89

$17.99 – $61.00 · 41 listings

Grading premium

+933%

Graded average over raw average

Price by grade

Average sale price by grade
Grade Average Range and sales
Raw $33.89 $17.99 – $61.00 · 41 listings
Grade 10 $350 $340 – $360 · 2 sales

Estimate from eBay listings after removing bundles, wrong sets and outliers. Small samples move a lot.

About this card

Background compiled from public web sources. Check it before you buy or sell.

Market outlook

Rising Outlook 6/10

Graded high-end sales show premium pricing for perfect 10s, driven by rookie hype in fresh 2025-26 product.[1]

Next months. Stable to slight rise with spring hobby momentum.

Long term. Potential growth if Schaefer secures NHL role, dependent on career trajectory.

History

Matthew Schaefer is a promising rookie hockey player for the New York Islanders, featured in the 2025-26 Upper Deck Allure set as an Extended Rookie card, highlighting his emerging significance in the NHL prospect scene.[2]

First released in the 2025-26 Upper Deck Allure Hockey set, with hobby box breaks documented in late 2025.[3]

  • Designated as Extended Rookie variant #AR-MS, including parallels like Black Rainbow and Color Flow Red-Orange.[1][4]
  • Part of Upper Deck Allure's premium insert lineup with Color Flow and Rainbow Foil variants.[1]
  • Rookie card status confirmed across multiple parallels, appealing to Islanders collectors.[2]

Rarity and print run

Tier
Rare
Print run
Low
First printed in
2025-26 Upper Deck Allure
Demand
Medium
Supply
Low
  • Extended Rookie Black Rainbow parallel #AR-MS is a low-print chase variant.[4]
  • Color Flow inserts like Red-Orange add parallel scarcity.[1]
  • 2025-26 Allure hobby-exclusive nature restricts supply.[3]

Collector notes

Condition. Inspect for centering issues on foil surfaces, edge chipping common on Rainbow and Color Flow parallels, surface scratches from handling on extended rookie stock.

Storage. Use semi-rigid top loaders with team bags, store in cool, dry environment away from sunlight to preserve foil vibrancy, avoid stacking with heavier cards.

Authenticity. Check Upper Deck hologram and card stock thickness; fakes often have dull foil and misaligned numbering; authenticate via graded/graded for high-value grades, verify eBay sales against official checklists.

Sources: sportscardspro.com, mycardpost.com, youtube.com

Card details

Name
Matthew Schaefer
Game
Hockey
Set
Allure (AR-MS)
Number
AR-MS
Year
2025-26
Rarity
Rookie
Variant
Extended Rookie
Language
English
Manufacturer
Upper Deck
Illustrator
N/A
Identification
Matched on eBay
Certificate
#4D5DFF37A06A
Graded on
Apr 9, 2026
Views
349

Grade your own card. Two free scans a month, a result in about two minutes.

Grade your card free

The TCGAI Score is an AI estimate made from photos. It is not an official grade and third-party grades may differ. Not affiliated with any grading company. Read the AI disclaimer.