TCGAI.PRO Willie Mays 1954 · 1954 Topps · #90
8.5 Near Mint-Mint+
Cen
10
Cor
8
Edg
9.5
Sur
10
Hold
Willie Mays card, TCGAI Score 8.5

Certificate #510C5C8747AF · Baseball

Willie Mays

1954 Topps · #90 · 1954

Near Mint-Mint+ Hold

Hold. Often worth as much raw. Keep it or sell it raw.

Estimate, not an official grade.

Share on X

Condition report

Each check is scored out of 10 on both sides. The lowest one caps the TCGAI Score.

Front No flaws
Back No flaws
Sub-grades out of 10, front and back
Check Front Back
Centering 10 10
Corners 8.5 8
Edges 10 9.5
Surface 10 10
Whitening 10 9.5
Holo / foil 10 10

What the AI found

Flaws visible at the photo's resolution. A grader under magnification may find more. Marks on the photos show the area named, not an exact spot.

No defects listed at this photo resolution.

What this card sells for

An estimate from recent listings, not an appraisal. Prices in USD.

Graded 9

$2,400

1 sale

Raw, ungraded

$917

$390 – $1,249 · 5 listings

Grading premium

+162%

Graded average over raw average

Price by grade

Average sale price by grade
Grade Average Range and sales
Raw $917 $390 – $1,249 · 5 listings
Grade 1 $300 $300 – $310 · 4 sales
Grade 2 $470 $390 – $580 · 7 sales
Grade 3 $850 $690 – $920 · 4 sales
Grade 5 $880 1 sale
Grade 6 $2,400 1 sale

Estimate from eBay listings after removing bundles, wrong sets and outliers. Small samples move a lot. Prices calculated with low identification confidence. May correspond to a different card. | Muestra insuficiente (graded=0, validListings=31, mínimo=5). Rango estimado con baja confianza.

About this card

Background compiled from public web sources. Check it before you buy or sell.

Market outlook

Stable Outlook 9/10

Recent sales show minor fluctuations (e.g., graded 5 down 2% in 30 days, graded 10 slight decline) but overall stability for vintage Mays cards driven by collector interest[1][3]

Next months. Stable with potential minor dips in mid-grades due to economic factors

Long term. Rising as supply of high-grade examples diminishes over time

History

Willie Mays was a legendary center fielder for the New York/San Francisco Giants, renowned for his exceptional hitting, fielding, and base-running, earning 24 All-Star selections, 12 Gold Gloves, two MVP awards, and induction into the Baseball Hall of Fame in 1979 as one of the greatest all-time players.

First released in 1954 as part of the Topps baseball card series in the United States.

  • This is not Willie Mays' true rookie card (his rookie is 1951 Bowman #195); the 1954 Topps #90 is his second-year card.
  • Features Mays in New York Giants uniform, capturing him early in his Hall of Fame career.
  • Iconic card from the highly regarded 1954 Topps set known for its vibrant design and key Hall of Famers.

Rarity and print run

Tier
Uncommon
Print run
High
First printed in
1954 Topps Baseball
Demand
High
Supply
Medium
  • Base card from high-print run 1954 Topps set, but high grades (graded 8+) are scarce due to age and production quality
  • Population reports show hundreds in mid-grades but few gems (e.g., graded 10 pop low)

Collector notes

Condition. Check for centering issues common in 1954 Topps (often off-center top-to-bottom), print defects like wax stains or scratches, edge chipping, corner wear, and centering (aim for 50/50 all-around for high grades); common flaws include tape residue, writing, and miscuts.

Storage. Store in card sleeves with top-loaders or semi-rigid holders in a cool, dry environment away from sunlight; use acid-free materials and avoid stacking without protection to prevent scratches.

Authenticity. Examine print quality, paper stock (1954 Topps has specific yellowish tint and black-and-white backs), and borders for authenticity; check for modern printing dots or overly sharp edges on fakes; professional grading by graded, graded, or graded recommended for verification.

Sources: sportscardspro.com, cardladder.com, sportscardinvestor.com, threestarssportscards.com, deanscards.com

Card details

Name
Willie Mays
Game
Baseball
Set
1954 Topps (Unknown)
Number
90
Year
1954
Rarity
Base
Language
English
Manufacturer
Topps
Illustrator
Unknown
Identification
Matched on eBay
Certificate
#510C5C8747AF
Graded on
Apr 23, 2026
Views
246

Grade your own card. Two free scans a month, a result in about two minutes.

Grade your card free

The TCGAI Score is an AI estimate made from photos. It is not an official grade and third-party grades may differ. Not affiliated with any grading company. Read the AI disclaimer.