TCGAI.PRO Mets 1967 Rookie Stars (Tom Seaver / Bill Denehy) 1967 · Topps · #581
9.5 Gem Mint
Cen
10
Cor
9.5
Edg
10
Sur
10
Submit
Mets 1967 Rookie Stars (Tom Seaver / Bill Denehy) card, TCGAI Score 9.5

Certificate #CAA0C6F40A4D · Baseball

Mets 1967 Rookie Stars (Tom Seaver / Bill Denehy)

Topps · #581 · 1967

Gem Mint Submit

Submit. A real shot at the top grade. The fee pays back.

Estimate, not an official grade.

Share on X

Condition report

Each check is scored out of 10 on both sides. The lowest one caps the TCGAI Score.

Front No flaws
Back No flaws
50 50 50 50
Front 50/50 L/R · 50/50 T/B
48 52 49 51
Back 49/51 L/R · 48/52 T/B

Measured from the photo. Borders drawn wider than real so the offset shows.

Sub-grades out of 10, front and back
Check Front Back
Centering 10 10
Corners 9.5 9.5
Edges 10 10
Surface 10 10
Whitening 10 9.5
Holo / foil 10 10

Limited by Corners 9.5 microscopic fuzz on one corner

What the AI found

Flaws visible at the photo's resolution. A grader under magnification may find more. Marks on the photos show the area named, not an exact spot.

No defects listed at this photo resolution.

What this card sells for

An estimate from recent listings, not an appraisal. Prices in USD.

Graded 10

$2,550

$2,500 – $2,600 · 2 sales

Raw, ungraded

—

No raw sales found

Grading premium

—

Graded average over raw average

Estimate from eBay listings after removing bundles, wrong sets and outliers. Small samples move a lot. Muestra insuficiente (graded=0, validListings=2, mínimo=5). Rango estimado con baja confianza.

About this card

Background compiled from public web sources. Check it before you buy or sell.

Market outlook

Stable Outlook 9/10

Strong historical demand for Seaver rookie with recent sales showing minor short-term fluctuations but overall high value retention.

Next months. Stable with potential for slight increases in high grades.

Long term. Rising due to enduring collector interest in 1960s rookies.

History

Tom Seaver, a Hall of Fame pitcher for the New York Mets, shares this rookie card with teammate Bill Denehy, another pitcher whose career was less distinguished. This card is Seaver's only recognized mainstream rookie card and is the key card of the 1967 Topps Baseball set, highly sought after due to Seaver's legendary status.

First released in 1967 as part of the Topps Baseball set in the United States, specifically in the high-number series (534-609).

  • Tom Seaver's only official mainstream rookie card, shared horizontally with Bill Denehy.
  • Part of the high-number series, printed in lower quantities than earlier cards.
  • Features clean 1967 Topps design with narrow borders and green reverse border.
  • Seaver also appeared in a 1967 Mets team issue postcard set, but it is not considered a mainstream rookie.

Rarity and print run

Tier
Ultra Rare
Print run
Low
First printed in
1967 Topps Baseball
Demand
Very High
Supply
Low
  • High-number series with lower print run.
  • Condition challenges from narrow borders and centering.
  • Status as Seaver's sole mainstream rookie card.

Collector notes

Condition. Check for centering issues due to narrow borders; inspect green reverse border for edge wear; examine printed signatures for solid black without shadowing.

Storage. Store in protective sleeves and top loaders; maintain in low-humidity environment away from light to prevent edge wear and fading.

Authenticity. Fakes show shadowing behind printed signatures unlike genuine solid black; compare to authenticated examples; seek professional grading from graded or CSG.

Sources: cgccards.com, psacard.com, oldsportscards.com, sportscardinvestor.com, sportscardspro.com

Card details

Name
Mets 1967 Rookie Stars (Tom Seaver / Bill Denehy)
Game
Baseball
Set
Topps (TOPPS)
Number
581
Year
1967
Rarity
Rookie
Language
English
Manufacturer
Topps
Identification
Matched on eBay
Certificate
#CAA0C6F40A4D
Graded on
May 5, 2026
Views
187

Grade your own card. Two free scans a month, a result in about two minutes.

Grade your card free

The TCGAI Score is an AI estimate made from photos. It is not an official grade and third-party grades may differ. Not affiliated with any grading company. Read the AI disclaimer.